When volunteers raised part of the old feed store on Front Street North to pour a new foundation, they found the mummified bodies of two rats and a cat. The Seattle Times reported in 2006 that the cat was going to be preserved. So was a painted 1903 Owl cigar sign they found under a layer of siding. The restoration took three years and more than $250,000 in cash and in-kind donations, plus a great many volunteer hours.
Twenty years later, the building at 232 Front Street North is best known for five weekends of the year. It opens Thanksgiving weekend as the Historic Shell Holiday Shop. Inside, small handmade goods from local artists fill rooms that once held sacks of chicken feed. The shop feels the way it does for two reasons. The old building limits what fits inside, and the shop's rules decide who gets a spot on the shelves. Together they explain why it carries the goods it does.
A store long before it was a landmark
Selling things is the oldest job this building has had. The bright yellow pumps out front make it easy to forget that.
| Years | What the building was |
|---|---|
| 1903 | Nicholas Burke builds it as the N. J. Burke Flour and Feed Store |
| 1920s | Becomes a private residence |
| 1941 | James Hailstone and his family buy it and reopen it as a feed store |
| 1942 | Gas station added beside the feed business |
| 1990 | Feed store and gas station close |
| 2003 | Named an Issaquah landmark; restoration to its 1944 look begins |
| 2015 | Alison Lang starts the seasonal holiday pop-up |
| 2020 to 2021 | Roof work and dry-rot replacement |
The site's name still comes from its 1942 owners. In the Times story it is the Hailstone Feed Store and Shell Gas Station. The building sits on what used to be railroad right of way. That is why the cigar sign was painted on the back wall. In 1903 the back faced the tracks, and trains were the main way into town. The city bought the rail corridor along with the feed store and a restaurant next door. It then leased the feed store to the Downtown Issaquah Association. Greg Spranger led the volunteers who restored it. They used a 1944 black-and-white photo as their guide, and a large print of it hung in the front window while they worked.
Spranger told the Times he had grown up in Fullerton, California, and watched bulldozers wipe out history as Orange County grew. When he moved to Issaquah in 1980, he "didn't want to see it repeated." Erica Maniez, who directed Issaquah History Museums at the time, explained why this building mattered to the downtown historic district:
"The logging history is visible at the logging display on the south side of the historic downtown area, and the rail history is visible at the Depot. The feed store makes the farming industry visible."
So the farm-supply store became a museum of itself. The old drive-through garage on the north side now holds a mini-museum of auto tools, parts and old oil bottles. The pumps were painted to look new, but they no longer work. For most of the year, the Downtown Issaquah Association rents it out as a museum and meeting space. The garage and meeting room together hold up to 49 people. Every Thanksgiving weekend it goes back to selling goods.
Why everything on the shelves is small
A building sized for a 1903 feed business is a tight space for a gift shop, and the shop's rules reflect that. Lang's 2026 call for artists says she reviews original art, but "hanging and displaying original pieces is extremely difficult in the space." The rules add that "typically smaller items work best." That is why the list of what she looks for reads like a stocking-stuffer list. It covers jewelry, candles, textiles, journals, stationery, games, children's toys and small furniture. The Downtown Issaquah Association's listing describes what shoppers actually find the same way: jewelry, ceramics, cards, ornaments, journals, stickers and pins.
The space also limits how many makers can take part. On the shop's news page, Lang writes that she tries "to keep our artist number in the 30-40 range." She says she gets more applicants than that, and some are turned down simply because "we might just not have the space needed to properly display your work." She also groups items with similar styles and color stories, and she describes the final choices as "typically... mine alone." One curator works in a few small rooms. The result looks like a single collection rather than a hall full of separate booths.
Past makers include Bellissaquah. Lang has said the pop-up came out of her own retail experience and her interest in showing work by local artists, makers and designers.
The deal that keeps the makers away from the counter
The building limits how much stock fits. The shop's rules decide whose stock gets in and who stands behind the counter. Under the 2026 artist terms:
- Artists pay no table or booth fee and don't staff a booth.
- Everything is sold on consignment. Artists keep 60% of sales, and the shop's 40% commission covers insurance, display, processing fees and the venue.
- Stock arrives November 22 or 23 and gets picked up December 30 or 31. Artists are paid by January 30, 2027.
- Priority goes to early applicants, returning artists, and makers who are very local to Issaquah.
- Work made with generative AI is not accepted. Anything found to break that rule is pulled, and the vendor pays for any customer refunds.
Each of these rules affects what a shopper finds. With no booth fee and no shifts to cover, a maker who could never give up five weekends can still sell here. That opens the door to people who make things around a day job. The preference for very local makers is why so much of the stock comes from Issaquah and nearby. The AI rule means the store promises that everything on the shelves was made by a person, and it backs that promise with refunds. Because one person runs the counter for everyone, each item carries a tag with the maker's business name, an item number and a price. The shop also runs a web store, so you can browse online and pick up in person on Front Street.
By the organizer's count, 2026 is the twelfth year of the shop.
The weekends the old feed store is open this season
The shop is open Fridays through Sundays from noon to 6 p.m., starting Thanksgiving weekend and running through New Year's Eve. Here is how the season around it lines up:
- Thursday, November 19. The city holds its third annual Holiday Tree Lighting at Village Green Park, 2550 NE Park Drive, from 5 to 6:30 p.m. Mayor Mark Mullet is scheduled to light the tree at 5:15.
- Thanksgiving weekend. The Historic Shell Holiday Shop opens for the season.
- Saturday, November 28 and Sunday, November 29. The Historically Hip Artisan Market sets up outside the station from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. for Shop Local Saturday and Artist Sunday. Vendors also fill the Experience Tea and breezeway area.
- December 12 and 13. The artisan market returns for another weekend.
- Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. The shop is closed. Christmas falls on a Friday this year, so that weekend starts a day late.
- New Year's Eve. Last day of the season. Artists collect their unsold stock December 30 and 31.
On market weekends, the gift shop inside and the makers' tables outside run at the same time. That gives a shopper both the curated small-goods collection in the building and a wider spread of crafts on the sidewalk. The city's market listing mentions leather handbags, cashmere scarves, paper art, glass and paintings. Village Theatre's Come From Away also runs in Issaquah through the season, with dates beginning November 10, so a Front Street afternoon can turn into a night out. For more on how this stretch of downtown works the rest of the year, see our look at the address that runs downtown Issaquah's summer. Our Issaquah neighborhood page covers the wider area.
When the restoration wrapped up, a 1926 AA Ford truck was parked beside the pumps, and the Times reported that the truck runs even though the pumps don't.
At Porterhouse Property Group, we're always glad when a building that's more than a century old gets to keep its original job, even if only for five weekends a year. If you'd like to talk about Issaquah's historic downtown or any older home on the Plateau, connect with our Enumclaw specialists.